2 pg essay on who has the best arguement

An episode (The Howling Man) of the 1960’s TV show The Twilight Zone pitted Brother Jerome against a man whom Brother Jerome thinks is the devil. Each person argues his case. Brother Jerome argues the man is the devil. The man (imprisoned in Brother Jerome’s monastery) argues that he is an ordinary man, and that he has been imprisoned by a lunatic–Brother Jerome.

I want you to tell me who has the best argument–the man (who really is the devil) or Brother Jerome. Why? You will need to reconstruct some (or all) of their arguments. 2 pages

here is the link to video: https://www.dailymotion.com/video/x5avl4s