Brookhaven College Devices that Destroys Peoples Souls Response & Discussion

Suppose someone claimed to have a device that destroyed people’s souls, but otherwise had no discernible effect on that person. How would you evaluate such a claim? Is the claim that people have souls any more plausible? Why or why not?

Please refer to the grading criteria in discussion #1 for this and all future posts.

(complete after reading 2.2)